Monday, October 17, 2005

Antique Tractor Virtual Communities

Folks interested in antique tractors are some of the nicest people I know. Honest, trustworty and always willing to lend a hand. In the past 12 years of selling parts and tractor related merchandise I've only received 5 bounced checks and had one stolen credit card. In twelve years! And out of those 5 bounced checks, all were recovered except for one. Unfortunately it was a $600.00 rebuild kit, but as I look back I like to think it was my contribution to his Save the Tractor fund.

On-line communities are somewhat of a reflection of our off-line society. I say somewhat, because it seems people will say things to each other on the internet that they would never say face to face. Maybe it's the lack of eye contact, or we feel that our computer monitor is akin to a Darth Vader mask and some other persona temporarily takes us over.

But for the most part, on our own on-line Antique Tractor community at the YT Discussion Forums people are pretty darn helpful and kind to each other. For example, out of 1200 new messages posted each day, there might be 20 that have resorted to virtual fist fighting or name calling. If you think about it, that's less than 2% of the discussions. Looked at it that way it conjures up thoughts of the town of Mayberry.

Unfortunately that 2% or so of unkindly discussion ends up primariliy in one of the forums, Tractor Talk. The complaints I hear from others is endless. Most of the discussions in question start out as a political comment, or sometimes just the price of gas. People on each side of the political fence join in and you can almost sit there and count down the seconds to a complete conversational meltdown. I've asked that these conversations not be started at YT, for that very reason - the forum is like a little neighborhood cafe and right in the midst of it are people standing up and screaming. It makes everyone in the middle of their virtual sandwich want to walk out and not come back for a few days. So I delete those discussions, after all, it was made clear that these were unwanted and we have zero tolerance for disharmonious communications. Arguing is fine, but don't start bashing each other.

After deleting these types of discussions I see an onslaught of hate mail towards the site moderator (*me*), everything from threatening to sue me for violating their Freedom of Speech, to calling me a dictator and everything in between. And I get an equal onslaught of email thanking me over and over again for keeping the boards harmonious. I live my life in between a rock and a hard spot, if you will. I'm the kind of person who likes to make sure everyone is happy and having a good experience on the site. But it seems impossible to do that with so many people and it's disheartening. Of course I keep on trying.

To that end, last evening I stayed up late into the wee hours and created a new "OH Tee" forum. That's OT, or "Off Topic" for those lost in internet lingo. It's a place for Politics, Tractor Wars and other Controversial Conversations. I'm hoping that by making a place for people to talk and argue a bit about current events and such, that it will keep them out of the regular tractor forums where friendly folks, women, kids, grandma's and grandpa's just want to talk tractors and not politics. I hope it works out and keeps that 2% happy without disturbing the other 98% of the community.

The forum is unmoderated, and there is a disclaimer enouraging people to keep kids away and a good warning of what it's all about. I won't allow pornographic related conversation or anything close, and there is a "Report to Moderator" link on each post for people to alert me. If you're brave enough to take a peek at the new forum, here is the link. You've been forwarned! If you want to talk tractors just go to the regular forums.

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

I for one am extremely happy to see an O/T discussion board. It seemed that the Tractor Talk board was becoming increasingly the O/T board IMO. Now, hopefully I can find antique tractor related topics there instead of "I am tired of the price of gas" discussions.

Good for you and thanks!

Dan

Anonymous said...

Y'know, I've been moderating a set of game forums populated mostly by teens and I've seen just about everything you're talking about here.

We've generally avoided anything that's too heated most of the time. I've been called a fascist and other names in between when I moderate a comment, but I don't let it get to me.

It's really quite a fun hobby, being a moderator.

Anonymous said...

59allis,thanks for keeping tractors,tractors.I love your site,and I'm here every night.Keep up the good work.cw

Anonymous said...

Kim,

I've followed your site for several years, thanks for all the hard work. I'm an IT guy during the day, so I know where you're coming from.

I know one thing, you've got guts trying a forum like that again! Good luck, hope they keep at least some semblance of decency in there. I might cruise through there but I doubt I'll be posting.

Good thing I don't have to run your site, mine hasn't been updated in several years!

Keep up the great work!
Kerry
(kmiller, since there's apparently already a Kerry on your site)

Anonymous said...

Kim,been an afficiando of YT for years and literally live online.The creation & management of YT shows your dedication and love of the site which is seldom seen on even on smaller and simpler sites."Ya done good,girl".I can honestly say I find your decisions and management of problems superior to ANY other site I frequent.Some folks seem to thrive on creating discord and problems at any site they visit and your handling of such is without peer.Dunno why they can't comprehend"Your House,Your Rules",but then some folks could start a fight in a phone booth.
Keep On,Keepin On Kim :)

Donna. W said...

Yeah, what Joe said.

Anonymous said...

What's up Dear, are you really visiting this website on a regular basis, if so then you will absolutely take pleasant experience.

my website hack de castleville

Anonymous said...

Enjoyed reading this, very good stuff, appreciate it.

"The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing." by Archilocus.


Feel free to surf to my blog :: minecraft download

Anonymous said...

Hi there friends, its impressive piece of writing regarding tutoringand fully explained, keep it up all
the time.

Feel free to surf to my homepage; minecraft 2.0

Anonymous said...

What's up, yeah this article is really good and I have learned lot of things from it about blogging. thanks.

Feel free to visit my website: HowTo Password Hack Twitter Account

Anonymous said...

Hi there to all, how is everything, I think every
one is getting more from this web site, and your views are good in favor of new users.


Here is my blog bani24.ro

Anonymous said...

Without having a doubt, among the most desirable traits a man can possess is confidence.


Feel free to surf to my blog: the tao of badass tips ()

Anonymous said...

I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This post posted at
this web site is truly pleasant.

Feel free to surf to my weblog ... new jersey businesses

Anonymous said...

When commenting avoid flattery because flattery is a tell tale
sign of your need for approval, which is not a trait of
someone who is an alpha male. It's not sexist, it's not is
literally hard coded into our DNA as surely as our hair color or any other physical trait.
Centers for Illness Regulate and Prevention, about 38 percent of adults are making
use of option treatments.

Feel free to surf to my website ... Macho Alfa PDF

Anonymous said...

ecigarette, smokeless cigarettes, e cig reviews, e cigarette reviews, electronic cigarette reviews, e cigarette